Brooke and Paige Hyland: Why They Left Dance Moms?

For the bigger picture and full context, make sure you read our main guide on Brooke Aldc: From Dance Mom to Content Creator.
markdown
Brooke and Paige Hyland's departure from Dance Moms wasn't just a plot twist; it was a turning point that dramatically altered the show's trajectory and the lives of the Hyland family. The ripple effects of that decision continue to be discussed and analyzed by fans years later.
At a glance:

  • Understand the specific event that triggered Brooke and Paige Hyland's exit from Dance Moms.
  • Explore the legal aftermath and the lawsuit filed against Abby Lee Miller and the show's production company.
  • Learn how Brooke and Paige navigated life after the show, focusing on education and personal growth.
  • Consider the long-term impact of the Dance Moms experience on the Hyland sisters and their family.
  • Discover how the Hylands are dealing with current challenges, specifically Kelly Hyland's breast cancer diagnosis.

The Breaking Point: "Big Trouble in the Big Apple"

The catalyst for Brooke and Paige Hyland's exit was a heated confrontation between their mother, Kelly Hyland, and Abby Lee Miller during the episode "Big Trouble in the Big Apple." This wasn't just a typical Dance Moms argument.
Kelly Hyland felt Abby Lee Miller was unfairly favoring Maddie Ziegler and brought in a new dancer to replace her daughters. The tension culminated in a physical altercation between Kelly and Abby. Kelly was arrested for assault and harassment. The legal charges were later dropped after Kelly agreed to counseling and a restraining order, forcing her to stay away from Abby for six months.
The immediate aftermath was clear. Brooke and Paige Hyland were no longer part of the Abby Lee Dance Company (ALDC), or the Dance Moms show.

Legal Battles and Fallout

Beyond the immediate drama, the Hylands pursued legal action against Abby Lee Miller and the show's production company. They sought $5 million in damages.
Key Claim: The lawsuit alleged "defamation" and "emotional distress" stemming from Abby's "bullying" behavior.
While their intent was to hold Abby accountable for her actions and the emotional toll they took, the legal process ultimately proved unsuccessful. The case was eventually dismissed, leaving the Hylands with emotional scars but without legal recourse.

Life After Dance Moms: Education and Healing

One of the most significant aspects of Brooke and Paige Hyland's story is their commitment to moving forward after Dance Moms. They both prioritized education and personal growth.

  • Brooke Hyland: Focused intensely on academics, eventually graduating from Ohio University in 2019 with degrees in Marketing, Management Information Systems, and Business Analytics. She pursued a career in influencer relations before transitioning to content creation, proving her diverse skill set. You can learn more about Brooke's journey and current endeavors by checking out From Dance Mom to Creator.
  • Paige Hyland: Prioritized her education, successfully graduating high school in 2019. She chose to further her studies at West Virginia University, demonstrating her dedication to academic pursuits.
    This shift in focus allowed them to reclaim their lives outside the spotlight and pursue their own passions without the pressures and constraints of the dance competition world.

The Lingering Effects: Trauma and Resilience

The Dance Moms experience left a lasting mark on both Brooke and Paige Hyland. The high-pressure environment, combined with Abby Lee Miller's demanding coaching style, contributed to ongoing trauma.
They've spoken openly about the emotional challenges they faced. In particular, dealing with the aftermath of their mother's fight with Abby, a pivotal moment that defined their departure from the show. The sisters have demonstrated remarkable resilience in overcoming those obstacles, using their experiences to advocate for mental health awareness and promote positive self-image.

Navigating Today's Challenges: Kelly Hyland's Battle

The Hyland family is currently facing a new challenge: Kelly Hyland's battle with stage 3 breast cancer. This difficult situation has brought the family closer together as they provide support and encouragement for one another.
The Hyland sisters have used their platforms to raise awareness and funds for breast cancer research and treatment, demonstrating their commitment to helping others facing similar struggles. This ongoing support for their mother highlights their strength and unity in the face of adversity.

Practical Playbook: Decisions & Steps After a Toxic Environment

Leaving a toxic environment, especially one as public as Dance Moms, requires a strategic approach. Here's a breakdown of steps the Hylands unconsciously and consciously took that everyone can learn from:

  1. Prioritize Well-being: Immediately focus on mental and emotional health. This could involve therapy, spending time with loved ones, or engaging in activities that bring joy and relaxation.
  • Example: Brooke and Paige shifted focus to school and activities unrelated to ALDC.
  1. Establish Boundaries: Clearly define what you will and will not tolerate moving forward. Learn to say "no" to situations that could trigger negative emotions or recreate harmful patterns.
  • Example: The Hylands filed a lawsuit, even though it was ultimately dismissed, showing a clear desire to establish boundaries.
  1. Seek Support: Connect with a strong support system of family, friends, or professionals. Sharing your experiences and feelings can help you process the trauma and build resilience.
  • Example: They visibly rely on one another to this day.
  1. Reclaim Your Narrative: Take control of your story and how it's told. Share your experiences on your own terms, and don't let others define you by your past.
  • Example: Brooke and Paige’s social media presence allows them to share their lives authentically.
  1. Set New Goals: Focus on achieving personal and professional goals that align with your values and interests. This can help you regain a sense of purpose and direction.
  • Example: Brooke’s academic and career pursuits, and Paige’s college education.
  1. Practice Self-Care: Regularly engage in activities that promote self-care, such as exercise, mindfulness, or creative expression. This can help you manage stress and maintain a positive outlook.
  • Example: They emphasize wellness and positive body image on their platforms.

Quick Answers: Common Questions About The Hylands' Departure

  • Was the fight between Kelly and Abby the only reason they left? While the fight was the immediate trigger, underlying issues of favoritism, bullying, and emotional distress contributed to the decision.
  • Did Brooke and Paige want to leave Dance Moms? Initially, they may have enjoyed aspects of the show, but the toxic environment and escalating conflicts made it unsustainable for their well-being.
  • Are Brooke and Paige still close to the other Dance Moms girls? Brooke and Paige maintain relationships with some of the other dancers, but their priorities have shifted as they pursue their own individual paths. The group is set to reunite for Dance Moms: The Reunion on Lifetime in May 2024.
  • What are Brooke and Paige doing now? Brooke is a content creator and social media influencer, while Paige continues to work and travel, sharing her experiences online.
  • Do Brooke and Paige regret being on Dance Moms? While they've acknowledged the negative aspects of the show, they've also emphasized the lessons they learned and the opportunities it provided, indicating a complex perspective.

Actionable Close: Building a Healthier Future

The story of Brooke and Paige Hyland offers valuable lessons for anyone navigating challenging or toxic situations. By prioritizing well-being, setting boundaries, and reclaiming your narrative, it's possible to heal from past traumas and build a healthier, more fulfilling future. The Hyland sisters demonstrate that resilience and growth are possible even after experiencing intense public scrutiny and personal hardship.